HomeWest AfricaNoStrings

Nigeria: Benue State legislators pass anti-gay bill

The rights of sexual minorities in Nigeria are increasingly at risk, as the LGBT community remains a frequent target for politicians seeking favor with homophobic voters. The latest example is a new state-level anti-gay bill in Benue State.

Benue State's House of Assembly

Benue State’s House of Assembly

On Wednesday, Benue State’s House of Assembly passed the bill, which would criminalize all forms of sexual conduct between persons of the same sex. The bill, titled the “Same-Sex Marriage Prohibition Law, 2018,” is similar to the federal Same-Sex Marriage Prohibition Act [SSMPA] signed into law in 2014 by then president Goodluck Ebele Jonathan.

The SSMPA is considered unconstitutional by many legal scholars and LGBT rights activists because it violates rights guaranteed in the Nigerian constitution.

The Benue bill would prohibit “a marriage contract or civil union entered into between persons of same sex shall not be solemnized in a Church, Mosque or any other place of worship in Benue’’.

The bill also would prohibit the registration or recognition of gay clubs, societies and organizations, their sustenance, procession and meeting as well as public show of same-sex “amorous relationship” directly or indirectly, which is a violation of the right to freedom of association and expression, which are clearly stated in various sections of the Nigerian constitution and in charters and treaties that Nigeria has endorsed.

The Benue house Speaker, Mr. Terkimbi Ikyange, presided as the bill was passed in a plenary session after clause-by-clause consideration by the committee of the whole.

Speaking after the third reading of the bill, the Speaker said same-sex unions are alien to the culture and tradition of the state and must be prohibited.

It is unclear whether the state bill would impose penalties such as the 10- and 14-year prison sentences provided in the federal SSMPA. It is also unclear when the bill would take effect, including whether it needs approval from other Benue State officials before it would take effect.

Newspaper coverage of the Benue bill suggested different assumptions about whether the bill is about to become a state law or remains a proposal that might or might not become a law.

Several newspapers implied that the proposal has already become law. The Nation, for example, stated, “Benue Assembly outlaws same-sex marriage.” Leadership.ng, however, stated merely “Benue Assembly Passes Anti-same Sex Marriage Bill.”